Roy Orbison’s deliberate missed note in ‘Crying’
Roy Orbison was a titan of the music world, a professional whose work commanded respect not just from his massive audience, but from his peers. His career was defined by a seemingly effortless mastery of vocal performance and songwriting, a quality that earned him legendary status throughout the rock and roll era.
The praise he received was immense. Legends like Bruce Springsteen, Lemmy, and even the late Elvis Presley lauded him, calling him “arguably the first true voice in rock and roll” and “the greatest singer in the world.” This level of acclaim wasn’t accidental; it was built upon a foundation of genuine artistic excellence, demonstrated by his ability to pour his heart and soul into every song he recorded.
His influence extended into the realm of collaboration, culminating in his participation in the iconic supergroup, the Traveling Wilburys, a testament to the powerful creative chemistry he shared with some of the greatest songwriters of the age.
Yet, amidst this stellar career, there exists one sonic anomaly that has fascinated music historians: the infamous note in his masterpiece, “Crying.” While his professionalism was impeccable, this particular instance of imperfection has become the most talked-about detail of his recording history.
It is here that the story takes a curious turn. During the recording of “Crying,” Orbison appears to have hit a note that many listeners would deem wildly out of tune—a noticeable, almost jarring, ‘bum note.’ For someone of his undeniable vocal caliber, this mistake is astonishing, and yet, it remains a defining feature of the song.
The mystery deepens when we consider Orbison’s intent. He later revealed that he didn’t simply stumble; he deliberately allowed the note to remain slightly dissonant. He was so consumed by the emotional delivery—the despair and heartbreak he was conveying—that he let the musical ‘perfection’ slip away.
In an interview with NME in 1980, Orbison explained his mindset: “Immediately, I thought of a past experience and just retold that, was the way that came about. I couldn’t tell you right now what notes I hit at the end of the song, or anything.”
This decision transformed the mistake into genius. Instead of being a flaw, the slightly off-key note served to amplify the profound emotional weight of the performance. The raw, tearful affect that poured from his voice, coupled with the imperfect pitch, created an emotional resonance that was simply unparalleled. The mistake became an integral part of the heartbreak, making the note itself a powerful narrative element.
The resulting recording of “Crying” achieved massive success, reaching number two on the Billboard Hot 100 and topping the UK singles chart. It cemented Orbison’s distinctive sound, but it is perhaps more than just a commercial success; it is a classic example of how a single, seemingly imperfect moment can elevate a song into a timeless piece of music. That one missed note is not just a flaw in the recording; it is arguably the greatest missed note in music history.
Buy on Amazon
Credit
